Skip to content
Canonikal

How we rank

Which games we consider, how we play them, what the score weighs and what we never do. This is how every game in the canon is chosen, scored and kept current.

Illustration: three blocks of different heights under a balance scale

Which games we consider

Any finished game that players in the UK can buy or download today on at least one mainstream platform: PC, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation, Xbox, iOS or Android. New releases and older favourites are judged the same way.

How the shortlist forms

Reader suggestions, games we keep recommending to friends and smaller independent releases share one shortlist. Games with a clear idea and something of their own rise to the top. Nobody can pay, pitch or trade their way onto it.

How we play

At least one of us plays each game to its ending where it has one. Games without an ending, such as roguelikes and management games, get at least fifteen hours, including the later stages most players reach. Co-op games are played with another person. If we cannot play a game properly, we do not score it.

What the score weighs

Every game gets four marks out of five. The score is their weighted average, given to one decimal place.

Design, 30%
Is the central idea fresh, and does every system serve it? A familiar genre can still score well if it is put together with purpose.
Feel, 30%
What the minute-to-minute play is like in your hands: controls, pace, difficulty, sound and the moment a plan comes together.
Finish, 20%
Art, sound, performance and stability on the platforms we played, plus options such as remapping, subtitles and text size.
Fairness, 20%
Respect for your time and money: honest pricing, no pressure to buy, clear stopping points and nothing built to keep you playing against your will.

From score to tier

The canon is ordered by score; when two games tie, the higher Fairness mark ranks first. The score then sets one of four tiers, printed beside it on every review.

  • Essential4.5 and upAmong the best indie games we have played. Easy to recommend to almost anyone who enjoys games at all.
  • Canon4.0 to 4.4Excellent at what it sets out to do. Read who it suits, then go ahead.
  • Contender3.5 to 3.9A good game with clear limits, such as length, difficulty or pace, that some readers will mind.
  • For the devotedbelow 3.5Rewarding for fans of its genre, a hard sell for everyone else. Not a failure, just a narrow fit.

Time and money, always

Every review names a Checkpoint, a natural place to end a session, and a Costs line covering what a game can cost after the first purchase: paid DLC and expansions, optional extras, memberships needed for online play, season passes, daily rewards and any in-game shop or paid random items. If a game has none of these, the review says so.

Session and mood

The Session line gives the usual shape of play (solo, local co-op or online) and its mood, from calm to frantic. It is there to help you plan when in the week a game belongs, and it never changes a score.

Reading the file on each game

What you do
The actual activity, minute to minute, in one plain sentence.
Who it suits
Who will love it, and who should skip it.
Plays on
The platforms and PC stores we checked when we published. New versions arrive, so check the official page.
Session
Solo, co-op or online, and the mood.
Checkpoint
A natural place to stop.
Costs
Everything beyond the first purchase.
Age
A pointer to the official PEGI rating on pegi.info or the store page, which can differ by platform, plus a note on what the content is like.

What we never do

No paid placements, sponsored scores, affiliate links or adverts. No reviews written from trailers or press releases, and no invented player numbers. No preview of a review for its publisher. We do not sell, host or download games, take payments, or run competitions or prizes. Every picture is our own illustration, never official art.

Keeping reviews current

Links, platforms and extras are checked regularly. When an update changes how a game plays, we play it again before touching its score, and the review says what changed. Spotted something out of date? Write to us.